- #1

- 62

- 0

## Homework Statement

following on from my thread in the Nuclear physics subforum, I am trying to work out the equilibrium temperature of three isotopes (Neon) in a state of equilibrium established by thermal contact with a bath of neutrons at a temperature T.

## Homework Equations

[tex]\frac{[20Ne][n]}{[21Ne]}=exp(\frac{B(21)}{kT})[/tex]

[tex]\frac{[21Ne][n]}{[22Ne]}=exp(\frac{B(22)}{kT})[/tex]

where for example,

B(21Ne)=[Mass(20Ne) + Mass(neutron) - Mass(21Ne)]c[tex]^{2}[/tex]

square brackets [..] represent concentrations

This is the relavent data for Neon:

A Ab mass (amu)

20 90.92 19.9924

21 0.26 20.9939

22 8.82 21.9914

## The Attempt at a Solution

Using the equations to find T gives:

[tex]T=\frac{B(21Ne)-B(22Ne)}{kln\frac{[20Ne][22Ne]}{[21Ne]^2}}[/tex] (*)

Now, B(21Ne)-B(22Ne)

={[Mass(20Ne)+Mass(neutron)-Mass(21Ne)]}-{[Mass(21Ne)+Mass(neutron)-Mass(22Ne)]

=Mass(20Ne) + Mass(22Ne) - 2*Mass(21Ne)

which is NEGATIVE (for neon, as well as for other isotope triplets)!

Because the denominator of (*) is positive, the equilbrium temperature is NEGATIVE! Weisacker who calculated this temperature worked it out to be 2.9x10^9K. What am I doing wrong? (I work it out to be -4.6x10^9)