The Orion's Arm Universe Project Forums





Giant fusion reactor design project
#1
I hop around a couple of topics, and right now, the one that I'm in the middle of is asking "what if we made a really big fusion reactor?" No... like, not just big, but REALLY big. I have my first article up here, let me know if you have any trouble seeing it.

https://medium.com/@alanse/design-of-1-t...d9cea853d8


This is fairly specifically about magnetic confinement fusion, although I wasn't limiting myself to that. It wound up as the superior design given the prompt here. I'm mostly convinced that it would be a relatively long, giant, tube, using direct conversion. At this size the economies of scale kick in high gear and it stands to reason that the confinement troubles we have now would be basically totally solved, but I'm still somewhat unhappy with the prediction of superconductor materials needed.

Anyway, let me retrace the thesis here. If you have a civilization of the scale of Kardashev Type I civilization, but powered by fusion, they would require 10 million 1 GWe reactors. In other words, you wouldn't do that. That is too many reactors, and leaves efficiencies on the table from economies of scale. In fact, even the 1 TWe reactor is too small! You'd need about 10,000. Even the PWe scale isn't unthinkable.

This matters specifically because fusion, specifically, is highly scale-dependent. In fact, the whole point I'm trying to make is that we can't harness fusion right now because we can't build big enough. If you imagine these future large-scale space-faring civilizations this is actually a complete non-issue. This is an exciting claim, and because of that, I think we should dive further into it.


My original inspiration was Ron Maimon who was a big proponent of PACER. The provocative claim there is that we already had economical fusion in actual history! We just politically decided not to use it. However, this both isn't practical politically, and isn't obviously highly economical. My angle started as "PACER in space". Make a blast chamber in the center of Ceres, that will get you all the scaling you need! However this still requires the fusion primary and literal nuclear proliferation.

Let me give you the direction I'm going in now - I don't want PACER, but I want something that "proves" that increasing scale solves confinement for fusion. This can be done by using accelerators to heat a target inside a ball of fuel... but... like, really really hot. This requires a minimum energy investment but has no limit on the output, just add more fuel. This is almost certainly viable on the TW scale, although it's thermal only which I don't like.

My next jump would be to suggest that same thing, but with a continuous feed. This would put a minimum continuous Wattage, as opposed to a single shot energy. It would also be completely bananas. Like, Type I civilization might be too small. But for Type II... I am speculatively thinking of a fusion reactor that is half-way to a star. Importantly though, due to radiator physics, we would really like direct conversion. Totally half-baked here, but I imagine multiple manufactured fuel streams going at very fast energies (but small enough for Q>20) colliding into each other in an asymmetric way. This burns with either no confinement means, or a directional (shaping) confinement laser "throat" and produces fusion-energy plasma that gets collected into magnetic bottles that exist for the sole purpose of shaping to use in direct conversion energy converters. This wouldn't be PW, it would be much more, I don't even know how much. But would still be less than a literal star.

But that's all still completely un-substantiated.

Anyway, I also at some point want to cross-reference with the ideas here for large societies and their energy sources.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)